Are falling oil prices to blame for Jindal’s budget disaster?

By Robert Mann

To hear Gov. Bobby Jindal tell it, Louisiana’s projected $1.6 billion shortfall is due almost entirely to falling oil prices. In other words, it’s not his fault. Louisiana’s looming fiscal disaster is out of his control.

From the New York Times in a story published Friday:

In a phone interview, Mr. Jindal defended his record, attributing “the vast majority” of the shortfall to the downturn in oil prices and insisting that a shrunken state government was the goal, not an unfortunate side effect.

“Vast majority”? That would mean that Jindal claims more than $800 million of the anticipated shortfall for the next fiscal year is because of falling oil prices.

There is only one problem with Jindal’s story. Back in August 2014, fiscal experts were already projecting a massive, $1.2 billion budget shortfall.

Screen Shot 2015-02-06 at 10.34.33 AM


Here’s how the New Orleans Times-Picayune reported the news in a story on Aug. 14:

Louisiana state lawmakers got their first glimpse Thursday of next year’s budget gap that they’ll have to close, and it’s another hefty shortfall: $1.2 billion.

The grim news, delivered to the joint legislative budget committee, barely raised eyebrows at the committee hearing, after more than six years of such disappointing financial forecasts.

The shortfall is projected for the 2015-16 fiscal year that begins July 1. Gov. Bobby Jindal and lawmakers will decide in next year’s legislative session how to address the hole.

On Aug. 14, 2014, the price of a barrel of oil stood at $94.08. The projected Louisiana budget shortfall was $1.2 billion.

Screen Shot 2015-02-06 at 10.58.54 AM

On Feb. 6, 2015, the price of oil is $51.59 per barrel, and the projected shortfall is $1.6 billion — a difference of $400 million.

I’m no math major, but I don’t see how the vast majority of Louisiana’s budget shortfall could be attributed to falling oil prices, when those oil prices didn’t start falling until October 2014. Even then, on Oct. 31, oil prices stood at $80.54.

Jindal will spin the myth that oil prices have devastated his budget, something that is completely out of his control. He will count on the local and national media to ignore the stubborn fact that when oil prices were close to $100 a barrel, he still faced a $1.2 billion shortfall.

Oil prices aren’t Jindal’s problem. It’s his own mismanagement and reckless tax and spending policies that have created Louisiana’s fiscal mess.

This entry was posted in Bobby Jindal, Louisiana Politics and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Are falling oil prices to blame for Jindal’s budget disaster?

  1. Mary A Sternberg says:

    This is really important. If the NY Times didn’t include this info in their article, you should send the reporter your blog. I know it will probably be picked up and tweeted but that may not have enough impact…


    • Stephen Winham says:

      Excerpt from the NY Times article online: “But economists, policy experts and lawmakers of both parties, pointing out that next year’s projected shortfall was well over a billion dollars even when oil prices were riding high, turn to a primary culprit: the fiscal policy pushed by the Jindal administration and backed by the State Legislature.”


  2. Stephen Winham says:



  3. Robert Mann says:

    Great idea. I have done so. Thanks.


  4. d says:

    I guess it doesn’t matter which side of the isle your on its always someone else’s fault. The mark of a good politician these days is someone that can shift the blame. Whatever happened to the buck stops here?


  5. Robbie says:

    Louisiana voters approved the Stelly plan several years ago. The Legislature repealed it. Has anyone determined what our current status would be if it had not been repealed? There would still be a deficit, but how much would it be?


  6. Stephen Winham says:

    “The root of our current budget problems goes back to the decision in 2008, under Gov. Jindal, to repeal the Stelly tax changes that voters passed in 2002,” says Louisiana Budget Project director Jan Moller. “That has taken about six to seven hundred million dollars our of our tax base every year.” – from a recent post on the WRKF website.


  7. Timothy J Gegenheimer says:

    The next delusional adventure for Lil Bobby, will be on to Iowa and New Hampshire to lecture Obama on fiscal responsibility.


  8. earthmother says:

    Time to forward all these blogs to every news medium in Iowa, New Hampshire and anywhere else piyush goes, along with the message that Mr. “I’ve got the job I want” is also stealing his salary from the state of Louisiana.


Comments are closed.